When thinking about electric cars vs petrol/diesel in India, there are both strong reasons to prefer EVs — and real challenges we need to understand.
Over the last few years, electric cars have become more than just a green dream — they’re turning into a real way to reduce pollution in India.
New research shows that even today, electric cars commonly produce up to 38% less greenhouse gases over their lifetime compared to petrol cars.
What the Studies Say for India?
-
Up to ~38% lower emissions:
A study by IIT Roorkee & ICCT found that battery electric vehicles (BEVs) in India emit up to 38% less CO₂-equivalent per km over their whole life cycle (manufacture + fuel + driving etc.) compared to petrol cars. -
Heavy-duty vehicles (trucks, buses) also benefit:
For bigger vehicles like trucks and buses, BEVs still have lower life-cycle greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions than diesel or petrol ones, but the margin depends heavily on how clean the electricity grid is.
For example, BEVs using India’s current grid mix have significantly lower emissions, but when charged using renewable electricity (solar, wind, etc.), the emissions reduction can be much larger, sometimes around 75-80% lower than comparable fossil fuel vehicles. -
Grid carbon intensity matters a lot:
One major factor is how India generates electricity. A lot of power still comes from coal, which is carbon intensive. Because of that, the advantage of EVs over petrol/diesel cars is smaller than in regions where electricity is cleaner. -
Real-world driving & test assumptions make a difference:
Emissions estimates differ depending on whether one uses ideal test conditions or real traffic (stop/start, traffic jams, etc.). Real-world performance often involves more energy (e.g. losses in charging, driving inefficiencies), which can reduce some of the benefits, though BEVs usually still come out ahead. -
Future improvements will deepen the benefit:
As India’s grid gets cleaner (more renewables, less coal), and as vehicle technologies improve (more efficient motors, better battery life, lower manufacturing emissions), the gap between EVs and petrol/diesel cars will grow in favour of EVs.
What Holds Back the Cleanliness of EVs in India Right Now?
-
Coal in the electricity mix: Because so much of India’s electricity still comes from coal, charging an EV isn’t “clean” in absolute terms. The coal-based power plants emit a lot, and those emissions factor into the overall emissions of EVs.
-
Manufacturing & battery production emissions: The process of making a car, especially the battery, creates significant emissions. The more efficient the process, and the more renewable energy used in factories, the better the results.
-
Charging losses and inefficiencies: Energy is lost during charging, distribution, etc. Also, real driving (traffic, stops, hills) reduces efficiency compared to ideal test conditions.
-
Vehicle lifespan and usage: If you drive very little, or the car is used in inefficient ways, the advantage takes longer to show up. EVs pay off their “carbon debt” faster if driven more.
-
Charging infrastructure & grid issues: If charging happens during peak demand when coal plants are most in use, the emissions are higher. Having clean, off-peak charging and better charging infrastructure helps a lot.
What This Means for India?
-
Buying an EV now is still a strong choice:
Even with coal in the grid, EVs in India today are meaningfully cleaner than petrol/diesel cars (for many use cases). For those who drive regularly, the benefit shows up sooner. -
Location & how electricity is generated matters:
If you live in a state or city which already has more renewable power (e.g. more solar, wind), your EV will be much cleaner. In places with heavy coal use, gains are more modest, but still positive. -
Charging smart:
Charging during off-peak hours, using solar power or other clean sources (where possible), can improve how clean your driving is. -
Support clean energy & policy changes:
India is making plans to reduce coal’s share in the electricity grid, encouraging renewable energy growth, improving standards for vehicles & fuel. Policies that push clean electricity help EVs become even better. -
Think of the long term:
Even if the immediate emissions benefit isn’t as big as in some other countries, over the 5-10-15 years lifespan of a car, with cleaner grid & better battery tech, the gap will widen. So early adoption helps accelerate the transition.